In Defense of Biblical Fiction

ByCarolyn E. Jacobs

In college, I took a course on French Medieval literature. In it we studied a French miracle. The common people had no ability to read the Bible for a multitude of reasons. The active suppression of Biblical literacy is a discussion for another time.

Miracle plays were performed to teach biblical truths to an illiterate population. They didn’t necessarily portray miracles; the word is derived from the Latin for wonder. I love that. Because these plays truly leave you with a sense of wonder – in both senses. Awe at how holy God is and wonder as in seeking answers.

One play gave me a deeper appreciation for Jesus’s sacrifice and for His concern for those He loved. The impact was powerful enough I’m still talking about it four decades (!!!) later. It portrays an intimate conversation between Mary and Jesus in which he tells his mother about his imminent death. (I won’t spoil it – I might try my hand at recreating it one day.)

Did such an exchange take place?

Probably not.

Is creating a fictional story about Jesus heretical?

Maybe, maybe not.

What standards help us determine if a work is heretical or not?

Recently, Todd Friel of Wretched posted a harsh critique of Amazon Prime’s The House of David. 

In response, Jon McCray of Whaddo You Meme? posted a response.

If this interests you, I encourage you to watch both videos.

Here are some questions you can ask to determine whether Scripture is being twisted.
  • Does the work present itself as truth or a as a work of fiction designed to give a deeper appreciation for or understanding of the biblical text?
  • Does the work accurately represent the characters presented?
  • Does the work draw you into a closer relationship with Jesus?
  • Does it make you open your Bible to get a better handle on the truth?

If you haven’t watched The House of David yet, I encourage you to check it out. I don’t agree with every editorial choice, but it’s well done. And it’s not claiming to be authoritative. It’s an interpretation, filling in gaps where we just don’t know the answers.

 

 

 

Similar Posts

  • A Royal Welcome

    Holy Week, Part 2 The crowds going ahead of Him, and those who followed, were shouting, “Hosanna to the Son of David; BLESSED IS HE WHO COMES IN THE NAME OF THE LORD; Hosanna in the highest!” – Matthew 21:9 Tobiah’s lungs burned. Chest heaving, he held the stitch in his side. But none of that mattered. He’d run all the way to Jerusalem to warn Jesus,…

  • Betrayal

    Holy Week, Part 3 Tobiah was frustrated and elated at the same time. Frustrated because the crowds Jesus drew were so large Tobiah couldn’t get anywhere close. And elated because the crowds Jesus drew hung on his every word. In the days leading up to Passover, Jesus taught in the Temple, and the people were…

  • What If? – Shepherds

    “I’ve got a book for you.” That’s my tagline. This time, it’s one that will help you reflect on Jesus’s earthly ministry as we prepare to celebrate His death and resurrection. It’s a blended harmony of the Gospels broken into 40 days of readings. Although my recommendation comes a little late for this year, it’s…